An OTR truck driving on the highway near a waterway

7 Challenges In Full Truckload Freight Shipping And How An Lsp Overcomes Them In Any Market

scroll down for more
AN Webber Logistics

The freight shipping industry is often subject to volatility, with oscillations between periods of increased demand (up markets) and periods of reduced demand (down markets). Understanding these market dynamics is crucial for businesses that rely on freight shipping for their supply chain operations. In the complex and ever-changing landscape of freight shipping, third-party logistics providers (3PLs) and freight brokers have emerged as vital partners, adept at navigating both up and down markets through years of experience as the cycles ebb and flow.

This article presents the challenges in truckload freight shipping and explores how a knowledgeable 3PL broker helps overcome them, with case studies illustrating the impacts of a reliable 3PL partnership.

Challenges in Full Truckload Freight Shipping & How a 3PL or Freight Broker Helps in Every Freight Market

In the freight market, two primary scenarios occur — up and down markets. An up market, or carrier's market, emerges when the demand for capacity surpasses the supply of trucks and drivers, thereby driving up rates. A down market, or shipper's market, exists when the supply of trucks and drivers outweighs the shipment demand, causing a rate decline. These market variations present unique challenges for shippers, making it essential to strategically navigate these shifts. Third-party logistics (3PLs) and freight brokers play a crucial role in providing expert guidance and solutions that allow shippers to overcome challenges regardless of market conditions.

1. Rate Fluctuations

Rate fluctuations are a common challenge in the freight industry, influenced by factors like fuel prices, market demand, and economic conditions. These fluctuations can create uncertainty for shippers, impacting their budgeting and planning processes.

How a 3PL helps

Experienced 3PL brokers are able to predict and be ahead of market fluctuations, helping shippers navigate them expertly when they arise.

During an up market, periods of high demand and constrained capacity, freight rates tend to surge. Shippers may face challenges securing affordable transportation options due to limited carrier availability. However, a 3PL or freight broker can prove instrumental in this scenario. Leveraging their industry expertise and market insights, they can negotiate competitive rates on behalf of their clients, even during market upswings. Their vast network of carriers allows them to access diverse pricing options, ensuring that shippers secure the best possible rates for their shipments.

During periods of low demand or economic downturns, excess capacity is available, causing rates to decline. However, finding reliable carriers to transport freight at lower costs can still be challenging. Once again, a 3PL or freight broker comes to the rescue. Their expertise in managing capacity and load optimization allows them to consolidate shipments effectively, making freight more appealing to carriers. By leveraging a network of shippers and carriers, sophisticated route optimization algorithms, and advanced load planning tools, 3PLs can optimize transportation costs, enhance efficiency, and ensure timely deliveries, even in a market with an oversupply of capacity.

2. Supply vs. Demand

The equilibrium between capacity demand and freight supply significantly impacts the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of freight transportation.

How a 3PL helps

3PLs and brokers have long-standing relationships with carriers, allowing them to use rapport to leverage these relationships to secure capacity regardless of seasonality.

During peak seasons or periods of high demand, capacity shortages may lead to delays and higher costs for shippers. The high demand for transportation services can strain carrier availability, making it challenging for shippers to secure timely deliveries. However, a 3PL or freight broker proves invaluable in this situation. With access to an extensive network of carriers, they can swiftly respond to shifts in demand, ensuring reliable transportation.

During periods of low demand or economic downturns, an oversupply of freight capacity will be available. While this surplus can create opportunities for cost savings, finding reliable carriers remains crucial. A 3PL's expertise in load optimization comes into play, enabling them to consolidate shipments effectively and make freight more appealing to carriers. By doing so, they optimize costs and enhance efficiency, ensuring that shipments remain a priority for carriers.

3. Service Reliability

Maintaining consistent and reliable service levels is paramount in the freight industry.

How a 3PL Helps

3PLs track service scores internally and monitor performance to select the most reputable and reliable carriers.

In an up market, carriers may face increased pressure to handle a higher volume of shipments, leading to potential service disruptions. This can impact a shipper's reputation and customer satisfaction. However, a 3PL or freight broker can alleviate this challenge. They carefully vet carriers in their network, selecting those with a proven track record of providing reliable transportation services. By monitoring carrier performance and maintaining strong relationships, 3PLs can ensure that shipments are entrusted to carriers with a history of on-time deliveries and safe handling of cargo. In the event of disruptions, 3PLs act swiftly to find alternative solutions, minimizing delays and ensuring that shipments reach their destinations as planned.

During periods of low demand, carriers face reduced freight volumes, leading to potential service inconsistencies. A 3PL's expertise remains crucial in this scenario. They continue to diligently monitor carrier performance and maintain strong relationships, ensuring that service reliability remains a top priority. By doing so, 3PLs safeguard a shipper's reputation and navigate disruptions efficiently.

4. Load Optimization

This process entails arranging freight to maximize truck space, ensure safe transportation, and minimize costs. It requires understanding the cargo's dimensions, weight, and nature to avoid wasted space, cost overruns, and potential damage.

How a 3PL Helps

A 3PL/freight broker aids in this process by leveraging their expertise in planning and consolidating loads, utilizing advanced tools and software, and applying their knowledge across various types of cargo for quick, efficient decisions.

Freight consolidation is particularly beneficial in an up market. By pooling shipments, 3PLs ensure more reliable space utilization, reducing the impact of limited capacity. It also means that shippers may share the increased costs of transportation, which can be particularly advantageous when freight rates are high.

In a down market, consolidation can help shippers make their freight more attractive to carriers by offering larger, more efficient loads. This increased efficiency can lead to better freight rates and faster transit times.

In either market scenario, 3PLs can leverage sophisticated route optimization algorithms and advanced load planning tools to implement effective consolidation strategies to benefit shippers and carriers alike. These measures not only optimize costs but also ensure reliable and timely deliveries, enhancing overall supply chain performance.

5. Regulatory Compliance

The freight industry is subject to numerous, region-specific regulations, including safety standards, environmental regulations, and labor laws. Non-compliance can result in financial penalties, loss of business, and harm to a company's reputation.

How a 3PL Helps

3PLs/freight brokers alleviate this challenge with their dedicated teams that stay current with all regulations, ensure freight compliance, and provide advice on compliance best practices.

The rapid increase in freight volume during an up market brings amplified regulatory scrutiny. The 3PL's compliance team can keep pace with the heightened activity, ensuring every shipment adheres to the regulations. They understand the complexities of compliance and the importance of avoiding legal issues to safeguard the shipper's reputation.

That diligence remains the same in a down market. A 3PL's compliance team, by virtue of their expertise, continues to track and understand regulatory changes. This knowledge allows them to guide shippers on best practices for compliance and risk mitigation.

6. Limited Visibility

A lack of real-time shipment data makes delay management, facility coordination, and customer updates even more challenging — and may increase the risk of theft or loss.

How a 3PL Helps

Many 3PLs/freight brokers use advanced technology platforms to provide real-time shipment visibility. These systems allow for effective tracking, delay management, customer updates, and enhanced transparency.

A sudden influx of shipments during an up market might overwhelm traditional tracking methods, leading to a loss of visibility. A reputable 3PL, with its robust technology platforms, can ensure constant visibility amid the chaos. Shippers can anticipate and manage potential delays better, promptly update customers about their shipments, and decrease the risk of theft or loss.

Despite the reduced demand during a down market, maintaining visibility is key to optimizing operations and ensuring cost efficiency. 3PLs, with their real-time tracking systems, provide shippers the insights to manage their shipments effectively, ensuring they can adapt to the changing market conditions swiftly.

Utilizing advanced technology platforms, 3PLs provide real-time shipment location and status updates. This visibility improves coordination, enhances transparency, reduces risks, and contributes to a smoother, more predictable supply chain in any market.

7. Risk Management

The freight industry has inherent risks, including carrier reliability, freight damage, delay-related issues, and market fluctuations. Long-term risks include changes in market demand, compliance regulations, and the potential insolvency of carriers or suppliers.

How a 3PL Helps

3PLs/freight brokers, with their expertise in risk management, routinely assess carrier partners for reliable performance and financial stability. They also offer insurance and claims management services, protecting against damage or loss, and leverage their market understanding to facilitate proactive planning.

Risks become more pronounced in an up market. The high-paced nature can affect carrier reliability and increase the chances of freight damage or loss. 3PLs constantly evaluate their carrier partners for reliability, thus minimizing the risk of service disruptions. They also offer insurance and claims management services to protect against damage or loss.

On the other hand, a down market brings its own set of risks, including fluctuations in fuel prices, changes in market demand, regulatory adjustments, and potential insolvency of carriers or suppliers. A 3PL’s risk management expertise proves essential, as they are well-equipped to predict and plan for changes, helping to maintain operational stability.

The Power of Partnership with 3PLs or Freight Brokers in Full Truckload Shipping

Establishing a partnership with a competent 3PL or freight broker be a lifeline during challenging times for shippers. They offer unparalleled advantages, including load optimization, real-time visibility, regulatory compliance, risk management, and freight consolidation — all critical aspects that define the smooth flow of the supply chain in any market condition.

Success Stories: Illustrating the Power of 3PL and Freight Broker Partnerships in Full Truckload Shipping

Let’s take a look at the experiences of Jerome Warner, a customer from Harris Rebar. For Jerome, the problem-solving capacity of A.N. Webber revolves around providing reliability and consistency for specific jobs. Their collaboration on wind farms and specific tasks has borne fruit due to A.N. Webber's emphasis on consistency and speed, which in turn reduces issues. The service quality is exemplary, and the partnership has led to zero issues, thus showcasing the value A.N. Webber brings to Harris Rebar.

Jerome's sentiments are echoed by Dennis Spitler, another satisfied customer, who values the trust, integrity, and customer-focused approach of A.N. Webber. Despite facing challenges, A.N. Webber consistently maintains responsive communication. Dennis appreciates that they never shy away from responsibilities, even in challenging situations. Unique equipment, careful planning, and reliable execution are some of the key highlights of A.N. Webber’s service and value in full truckload shipping.

A.N. Webber's strategy of maintaining a local presence while providing comprehensive resources speaks volumes about its personalized touch in handling customer needs. The stories of Jerome Warner and Dennis Spitler underscore the potential of such partnerships and their capacity to streamline full truckload shipping in any market.

Navigate the Market with A.N. Webber

We've explored a spectrum of issues, from load optimization, freight consolidation, visibility, and regulatory compliance, to risk management. Despite the variance in market trends, the role 3PLs and freight brokers remains a constant, underlining their capability to provide timely and effective solutions.

Partnerships with such professionals allow businesses to convert the obstacles of full truckload freight shipping into opportunities. With their expertise, tools, and years of industry knowledge, 3PLs and freight brokers, like A.N. Webber Logistics, enable smooth operations even amid market shifts. They are invaluable aids in maintaining operational continuity, enhancing customer experience, and ensuring resilience in the face of any freight market condition.

Navigating the volatile freight shipping landscape requires more than just a keen understanding of market trends. It demands a reliable partner who can provide critical support when it's needed the most.

So, whether you're operating in an up market or down market, shipping different types of freight, like open deck freight shipping, don't hesitate to reach out to A.N. Webber Logistics. Our expertise will ensure your supply chain's stability and help you weather any storm that the freight shipping landscape might throw your way. Get a quote today, and let the power of partnership work for your business.


Subscribe to Updates
Stay up to date with supply chain solutions and answers to your burning logistics questions from trusted experts.
Thank you! You've been subscribed!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Shipping Solutions for Every Need

Each solution is designed to meet your unique needs, ensuring efficient, reliable freight management no matter the size or scope of your operation.

Dry Van

Ideal for an extensive range of freight types, our dry vans ensure a blend of versatility and protection against the elements.

Less Than Truckload

Our LTL services provide cost-effective solutions for shipping smaller freight loads. With careful planning and execution, we make sure your smaller shipments are delivered efficiently and economically.

Flatbed & Open Deck

Specialized loads require specialized solutions. Our flatbed services are perfect for oversized or irregularly shaped cargo. We provide the right equipment and expertise to ensure your cargo's safe and secure transit.

Dedicated Services

Ensure your cargo always has the capacity and equipment it needs with our dedicated shipping services. We offer dedicated fleets and drivers, guaranteeing consistent, uninterrupted service.

Refrigerated & Temp-Controlled

Ensure your temperature-sensitive cargo maintains the right conditions throughout its entire journey.


Explore your intermodal options as we handle the logistics for smoother shipments.

Expedited & Hotshot

Our expedited shipping solution delivers speed and reliability for time-sensitive freight. With precision scheduling and real-time tracking, we minimize transit times, getting your cargo where it needs to be—fast.

Warehousing & Distribution

Optimize your supply chain with our comprehensive warehousing and distribution services. From storage to inventory management, order fulfillment to delivery, we cover all your needs for end-to-end supply chain efficiency.


Streamline your supply chain with A.N. Webber Logistics in control, starting at the terminal.

(800) 939-9456

2150 US-45 Kankakee, IL 60901

© A.N. Webber Logistics 2023. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy